Hamptons Verified

Yes for an early bagel before a ferry or a beach run. Expect a line on summer weekends.

← Back to Coffee & Breakfast

Bagel shop · Sag Harbor · $

Goldberg's Famous Bagels (Sag Harbor)

The Sag Harbor Main St branch of the Original Goldberg's. Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels with a long list of schmears.

Specialty
New York bagels, breakfast sandwiches
Hours
Mon-Sat 6am-4pm, Sun 6am-3pm
Address
111 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone
+1-631-899-4834
Website
Year-round
Yes
Opens
Before 7:00 AM
Outdoor seating
No

Source: The Original Goldberg's Famous Bagels locations. Last verified 2026-04-11.

Browse every spot on Coffee & Breakfast.

Goes straight to a human. Not a public comment.