Photo coming soon — we're sourcing a verified image for this entry.
← Back to Farm Stands
🍎 Orchard · Water Mill · The Hamptons
The Milk Pail Farm Market
The Halsey family's apple market — a dozen-plus varieties from Fuji and Empire through Mutsu, Gold Rush and Pink Lady, plus the cider and baked goods that make it a fall institution.
⭐ Is it worth it? The best apple selection on the South Fork, and it's not close.
- Where
- 1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976, USA
Open in Maps - Hours
- Mon, Wed–Sat 9:30am–5pm; Sun 10am–5pm; closed Tuesday
- Phone
- 631-537-2565
- Website
- milk-pail.com
Year-round market; apples from the family orchard.
🌱 What they grow
- 🍎 Apples
- 🎃 Pumpkins
- 🌻 Sunflowers
🧺 Also sells
- 🍎 Apple cider
- 🥧 Pies
- 🧁 Cookies
- 🧁 Muffins
- 🫙 Jam
- 🌷 Flowers
- 🧺 Gifts
👩🍳 Cook what they grow
- 🍲 Pumpkin Soup with Sage Butter · Autumn
- 🍎 Cider-Braised Pork with Apples · Autumn
- 🎃 Roast Winter Squash with Kale and Cider Dressing · Autumn
- 🥬 Brussels Sprouts with Apples · Autumn
📍 Also in Water Mill
- The Milk Pail U-Pick Fields · Pick your own
- Hank's Pumpkintown · Pick your own
- Green Thumb Organic Farm · Farm stand
- Seven Ponds Orchard · Pick your own
Source: The Milk Pail official website · last verified 2026-07-28