Wedged between East Hampton and Montauk. The smallest of the major hamlets and proud of it. Stephen Talkhouse for live music, Indian Wells Beach for actual swimming, the farmstand at Amagansett Square.
Good for:Couples who want to disappear, Indian Wells Beach.
Skip if:You need nightlife or shopping.
Where they are
Every hotel, inn, and campground on the map. Tap a marker for the full card and booking links.
🏛️ Boutique / historic inn
🌊 Resort / oceanfront
🏡 Cottages / B&B
✨ Modern boutique
🏕️ Camping
Hotels & inns
We do not book for you. Use this as a shortlist.
Roundtree Amagansett
$$$$
Amagansett · Cottages
Couple·First date·In-laws·Romantic
Five private cottages on a quiet lane. Bikes provided. About as tucked-away as a hotel gets out here.