Eastland Farms

A Water Mill nursery on Montauk Highway that grows its own vegetable starts alongside the trees and tropicals — the place to buy the tomato plant rather than the tomato.

⭐ Is it worth it? Start your own garden here in May, then buy from the stands the rest of the year.

Where: 1260 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976, USA
Open in Maps
Hours: Seasonal — check operator site
Phone: 631-726-1961
Website: eastlandfarms.net

Growing and selling in Water Mill since 1993, with horticulturists on staff for plant selection and care advice.

🌱 What they grow

🌳 Trees
🌿 Shrubs
🌼 Perennials
🌸 Annuals
🌴 Tropical plants
🌿 Culinary herbs
🪴 Homegrown vegetable plants

🧺 Also sells

🧰 Tools
🪴 Containers
🏺 Garden decor

👩‍🍳 Cook what they grow

🍳 Asparagus with a Farm Egg and Brown Butter · Spring
🫛 Peas, Mint and Scallions · Spring
🌽 Sagaponack Sweet Corn, Three Ways · Summer
🍅 Tomato and Bread Salad with Mecox Bay Dairy · Summer

📍 Also in Water Mill

The Milk Pail Farm Market · Orchard
The Milk Pail U-Pick Fields · Pick your own
Hank's Pumpkintown · Pick your own
Green Thumb Organic Farm · Farm stand

Source: Eastland Farms official website · last verified 2026-07-28